Christmas as Imagined by John Paul II

“The Christmas wafer is the bread of reconciliation. (...) If God is reconciled with us, then I, a man, must be reconciled with my brother. We share this Christmas wafer with different people, sometimes very close to us, with whom we have a lot in common, but sometimes there is also something that divides us. And we share the Christmas wafer with distant people with whom we have very little in common”.
Nativity scene in St Peter's Square at the Vatican. Photo. Donatella Giagnori/ EIDON/REPORTER/ East News
The first Nativity scene in Greccio (Italy) arranged at the request of St. Francis of Assisi. The beginning of the Nativity scene tradition.
Late 15th century
The origin of the Christmas tree tradition; the first accounts come from Germany (Alsace).
Pope Paul VI blesses for the first time the statues of the Infant Jesus brought by children to St Peter's Square from the home crèche on the third Sunday of Advent. This custom has been continued ever since.
At the request of John Paul II, the Christmas tree and the Nativity scene are erected for the first time in St Peter's Square in Rome.
A Christmas tree from Poland, from Księżówka, made its way to the Vatican.
Traditional celebrations of Christmas in Italy differ from those in Poland. On the Apennine Peninsula, as in many countries around the world, Christmas is not celebrated on Christmas Eve, but on Christmas Day - 25 December. The custom of sharing the Christmas wafer during a festive Lenten dinner is unknown. The dinner on Christmas Eve is often held in a festive atmosphere, but is not central to the celebrations. The dishes are also completely different - they represent Mediterranean cuisine, which varies from region to region.

After the successive pontificates were held by Italians for many centuries, the appearance of a Pole on the papal throne caused quite a stir in many areas - also in the sphere of Christmas customs. The Pope had no intention of breaking away from his native traditions and, with his colleagues, celebrated Christmas Eve no differently than he had previously done in Kraków.
Caroling into the night
Highlander band in the Paul VI auditorium at the Christmas wafer meeting in 1996. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

Karol Wojtyła saw great value and deep sense in specifically Polish Christmas traditions. This is what he said about carols as the Archbishop of Krakow, in 1973, during a meeting with the Jesuit academic community: "Christmas in Poland is something quite special. (...) I think that it expresses the genius of the Polish soul in a special way - in the Christmas experience, in everything that this Christmas experience has shaped in the history of our religion, Christianity and culture. (...) This is not a coincidence that there are so many Christmas carols in Poland, certainly more than in the traditions of other nations. This is not a coincidence. It is very precise evidence of the specific nature of the Polish soul, of its attitude to God incarnate, to the mystery of the Incarnation."

He found this particularity in carol singing, which he adored. As the Metropolitan of Kraków, Wojtyła would invite a large group of his friends to sing carols at the bishops' house at  3 Franciszkańska Street. Christmas singing also took place in other places, for example in the homes of his friends, the Ciesielski and the Poźniak families. "We used to sing carols into the night, singing all the verses to the end. He loved it so much that he came to us every winter during the carol singing period," recalls Maria Poźniak. Already in those days he liked to sing with THE second voice and compose stanzas on the spot, referring to the situation or the participants of the meeting, especially to the melody of the Highlander pastoral "Oj, Maluśki, Maluśki". [Oh, sweet little one, sweet little one]
Theology of carols
Caroling Highlanders in St. Peter's Square in the Vatican. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

In the Vatican, the Pope had his favourite canticle book, from which he sang memorably, together with his guests, throughout the Christmas season - both in the Vatican and in Castel Gandolfo. “I can't even count these meetings,” recalled the secretary of John Paul II, Archbishop Mieczyslaw Mokrzycki. Through such energetic carol singing with his entourage and guests, he not only soothed his longing for the homeland and continued the tradition he had started while still a youth pastor, but also delved into the meaning and significance of Christmas.

It is easy to treat carol singing purely as part of the festive atmosphere and social entertainment. Common singing brings joy and unites people. John Paul II also paid attention to the depth of thoughts and meanings contained in the texts of Polish carols. During the Christmas meeting with Polish pilgrims in 1996, he spoke about the carol “God is born”: "«God is born, the power trembles, the Lord of the heavens is unveiled! The fire solidifies, the brightness darkens, the boundaries of the Infinite»". In these words, the poet captured the mystery of the incarnation of the Son of God. Using contrasts, he expressed what is essential to this mystery: here the Infinite God, while assuming human nature, at the same time accepted the limitation, the finiteness inherent in creation."
Bread of reconciliation
The Christmas wafer with Poles in the Paul VI hall - 1990. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

Another specifically Polish custom, cultivated by John Paul II in the Vatican, was the sharing of the Christmas wafer. He symbolically shared it with the pilgrims who had arrived from Poland during the traditional meeting with them in the Paul VI hall, a few days before Christmas. He also had the habit of attaching a wafer to the greeting cards he used to send out at Christmas. He shared Christmas wafer personally with his collaborates at the traditional Christmas Eve dinner on 24 December. This supposedly initially upset the Western European hierarchy, who, not being familiar with this custom, associated the Christmas wafer with the host.

This custom was a part of his understanding of Christmas not only as a liturgical celebration of the feast, but also as a time of universal reconciliation, brotherhood and a call for peace. This is what he said about it in 1983: “The Christmas wafer is the bread of reconciliation. (...) If God is reconciled with us, then I, a man, must be reconciled with my brother. We share this Christmas wafer with different people, sometimes very close to us, with whom we have a lot in common, but sometimes there is also something that divides us. And we share the Christmas wafer with distant people with whom we have little in common (...) In this wafer we become a brother and a sister. Brothers and sisters, as God perceives us".
Empty space
The Christmas wafer with Poles in the Paul VI hall - 1993. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

 Special preparation of the table for Christmas dinner occupies an important place in Polish Christmas Eve customs. Twelve traditional Lenten dishes, the hay and the Christmas wafer. This is all complemented by leaving one empty space available. There are many explanations for this custom - some perceive it as a tribute to the deceased who are supposed to share the dinner with us, while in the borderland tradition it is sometimes referred to as waiting for an exile to return from Siberia. The most basic sense is surely that of ordinary human openness to a neighbour in need. Also in the Vatican, at the Christmas table of John Paul II, despite the large number of people present, there was a vacant place setting.

How the Pope understood its meaning, we can learn from his message during the Christmas wafer meeting with Poles in 1992: "In accordance with our millennial Christmas tradition, in reference to that empty plate of Christmas wafers that one places on the Christmas Eve table for an unknown stranger, for an unknown guest. And here is a special guest, a guest who wants to come into the circle of his family from under his mother's heart. Is it possible, without much exposure to terrible remorse, to close the door on him? Let him die? Let him starve to death? May he die in the cold?" And, further on: "There are of course various other forms in which the words of John's Gospel can be repeated. This is certainly the case. There is certainly also a system dimension to this. Can't the system of human life, socially, economically, be such that some people remain outside the door?"
Nativity scene and Christmas tree
John Paul II at the nativity scene in St Peter's Square. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

Apart from the specifically Polish customs, there are also some that do not astonish in Italy. The tradition of decorating the Christmas tree, which originated in Germany, is also practised on the Apennine peninsula. Nativity scenes are known all over Europe and the arrangement of the Nativity scene with live animals originates from the very heart of Italy - for the first time such a crib appeared under the inspiration of St. Francis at Greccio, in 1223. Therefore, the tree, or the Cracovian nativity scenes, appearing in large numbers in the apartments of John Paul II during the Christmas season, was not a surprise.

However, the public presentation of a huge Christmas tree and the Nativity scene at  St Peter's Square in 1982 caused an uproar, with rumour spreading that it was considered by some Italian church dignitaries to be incompatible with the solemnity of the place. In the end, however, not only was this custom never abandoned, but it was actually turned into the annual tradition. Since then, every year the Christmas tree at St Peter's  Square has been a gift from a different European region. A spruce from the garden of the so-called Księżówka retreat house in Zakopane came to the Vatican in 1997.

For John Paul II, the decorated tree also carried a deep meaning: "It symbolises the value of life, because in winter the evergreen fir tree is a sign of life that does not die. (...) it evokes the «tree of life», the figure of Christ, the God's greatest gift to mankind," the Pope said in his Angelus prayer on 19 December 2004. In another speech, he pointed out to the link between the Christmas tree and the tree of the cross.
Call for peace

Urbi et Orbi Message 1996. Photo. CMJP2 Archive

No less important than the festive customs were the official papal speeches at Christmas. The solemn midnight pastoral service is an ancient tradition that unites Christians across denominational divides. The mess celebrated at St Peter's Square had always attracted innumerable crowds.

The solemn Urbi et Orbi message delivered on Christmas Day from the balcony of the Basilica is also an element of Christmas much older than the pontificate of John Paul II, but in his time the message sometimes took the form of a poetic prayer. Broadcast through the media worldwide, it was yet another opportunity for him to highlight the message of peace prevalent during the Christmas season. John Paul II usually referred to specific events, praying for example for the victims of the conflicts in Darfur or Iraq. After his message and before the Apostolic Blessing, the Polish Pope offered his greetings to the faithful in dozens (at the end of his pontificate even in 62) of languages.

Many of these speeches and homilies, listened to by large crowds of the faithful, marked the style of John Paul II's pontificate. A very striking example can be found in the last Urbi et Orbi message, delivered on 25 December 2004:

Before the crib where you lie helpless,
let there be an end to the spread of violence in its many forms,
the source of untold suffering;
let there be an end to the numerous situations of unrest
which risk degenerating into open conflict;
let there arise a firm will to seek peaceful solutions,
respectful of the legitimate aspirations of individuals and peoples.

Since the pontificate of Paul VI, it has also become customary to celebrate the World Day of Peace on the New Year's Day and to deliver an annual papal message to mark the occasion. John Paul II continued this tradition by addressing specific challenges to peace in his speeches, such as the lack of religious freedom and the need to combat poverty.

The Pope blessing the faithful during the Angelus on 12 December 1999. Photo. Gabriel Bouys AFP/East News
John Paul II Quotes about Christmas
About the Christmas tree:
The message of the Christmas tree is consequently that life stays ‘evergreen’ if we make a gift of it: not so much of material things, but of life itself:  in friendship and sincere affection, in fraternal help and forgiveness, in time shared and reciprocal listening. (Angelus, Fourth Sunday of Advent, 19 December 2004)
About the Nativity scene:
Small or large, simple or elaborate, it is a familiar and most vivid representation of Christmas. The Nativity scene is a feature of our culture and art, but above all it is a sign of faith in God, who in Bethlehem came ‘and dwelt among us’ (Angelus, Third Sunday of Advent, 12 December 2004)
About the Christmas wafer:

The Christmas wafer is texactly the bread of reconciliation. God comes to man, God offers us reconciliation with himself.... And from here he arises, as it were man's first response. If God is one with us, if Christ is born in Bethlehem, then I, as a human, must be reconciled with my brother (message to Poles attending the Youth Meeting in Rome, 1 January 1983).
About an empty seat at the table:
It is a beautiful custom to leave one seat free at the table, for someone who may come from the road, for a stranger. These simple gestures mean a lot. They symbolize the goodness of the human heart, which sees in another person – especially in a person in need – the presence of Christ and calls to bring a brother and sister into the atmosphere of family warmth, according to the old polish saying: ‘Guest at home – God at home’. (message to Poles, 20 December 1997).

About a baby in a crib:

This is the icon of Christmas: a tiny newborn child, whom the hands of a woman wrap in poor cloths and lay in a manger. (Homily during Midnight Mass, Christmas, 24 December 2002)

The Child laid in a lowly manger: this is God's sign. The centuries and the millennia pass, but the sign remains, and it remains valid for us too – the men and women of the third millennium. It is a sign of hope for the whole human family; a sign of peace for those suffering from conflicts of every kind; a sign of freedom for the poor and oppressed; a sign of mercy for those caught up in the vicious circle of sin; a sign of love and consolation for those who feel lonely and abandoned.
A small and fragile sign, a humble and quiet sign, but one filled with the power of God who out of love became man. (Homily during Midnight Mass, Christmas, 24 December 2002)

Event Place
Choose location...
Persons index:
Geographical index: